The StoryGraph vs Goodreads: Which one fits your reading life?

For those of us who like logging our reading digitally, finding the right book tracking app is an intensely personal choice. In the last few years, the great debate centers around two popular choices: The StoryGraph vs. Goodreads.

Like many readers in the early 2000s, Goodreads was my introduction to the world of online book tracking. I went from writing my book lists on looseleaf paper and sticking them in a binder, to neatly tracking them online—and being able to see what my friends were reading, too!

But as I got older, my reading habits matured and grew right along with me. I yearned for a book tracking app that could act as a true companion to my modern reading life, all while aligning with my values. 

I’ve used the free version of The StoryGraph for a few years now, and I’m a big fan of how they prioritize tools that readers genuinely want. My goal with this post is to give you a thorough understanding of The StoryGraph vs. Goodreads platforms, how their features compare, and how to decide which one’s right for you. 

StoryGraph vs Goodreads header image featuring mystery books in the background.

Some links are affiliate links to Bookshop.org, and I may earn a small commission. A portion of every sale supports indie bookstores, too!

The StoryGraph vs Goodreads at a glance

The StoryGraph and Goodreads are both social book cataloguing websites with accompanying mobile apps. 

Goodreads was founded in 2006 and was bought by Amazon in 2013. Since then, the platform has grown to over 150 million users, making it the book tracking app with the largest user base by far.

In contrast, The StoryGraph was founded in 2019 by software engineer Nadia Odunayo, who built the app with features requested by the Goodreads community, and readers broadly. As of 2026, they have over 5 million users. 

The biggest StoryGraph vs Goodreads differences appear once you move beyond the basics. Both apps let you organize your TBR, track books you’re currently reading, log DNFs, and rate and review books—but they take very different approaches to the overall reading experience.

The StoryGraph vs Goodreads high-level overview: 

CategoryGoodreadsThe StoryGraph
Best forSocial readersMood readers
Overall feelSocial book trackerPersonalized book tracker
RecommendationsPopularity and community-basedPreference-based
Reading statsBasicDetailed graphs and charts based on moods, genres, authors, and more
Reading goalsAnnual book goalAnnual book, hours, and pages goals
ReviewsLargest review communitySmaller, thoughtful community
CommunityExcellentGrowing
Buddy readsNoYes
Content warningsNoYes
DNF trackingYesYes
Half-star ratingsNoYes
Kindle integrationYesNo
Kobo integrationNoYes
Import from Goodreads—Yes
OwnershipAmazonIndependent, Black-woman owned
PriceFreeFree (optional Plus plan)
Best if you…Want a social reading networkWant recommendations based on your preferences and mood

✦ Editor’s note

If neither Goodreads or The StoryGraph sound quite like what you’re looking for, there are plenty of Goodreads alternatives built around different priorities, from detailed reading journals and book clubs to private tracking and personal library organization.

Why so many readers are leaving Goodreads

Reading culture has changed substantially over the last 25 years, thanks to the rise of mobile phones, the internet, and *gestures wildly at the world around us.* Reading and literacy rates are plummeting in the U.S. And yet, there’s a growing subset of folks—particularly in online communities like Bookstagram and BookTok—who are defying the odds by reading multiple books a year. 

Despite being the incumbent on the scene and having a clear market advantage, Goodreads is failing to deliver a user experience that’s worthy of the use cases modern readers need it for. 

A quick peruse of the r/goodreads subreddit quickly shows some of Goodreads users’ frustrations. 

In no particular order, here are five of the most common complaints:

  1. The user interface feels out of date and is often slow or glitchy.
  2. No half-star ratings.
  3. Poor search functionality to find book recommendations.
  4. No manual dark mode functionality. (Although Android offers a native option tied to your system theme.)
  5. No enhanced stats or rich analytics. 

Why these basic features aren’t offered—despite years of user feedback—can be explained by another reason users are leaving Goodreads: Amazon. 

In 2025, Amazon announced job cuts that impacted the Goodreads and Kindle teams. It’s widely speculated that Goodreads is allegedly operating in a “keep the lights on capacity,” or KTLO, as it’s commonly referred to in the tech industry. 

As a reader, I do my best to avoid buying products on Amazon or from Amazon-owned companies, given their negative impact on the book industry, independent bookstores, and libraries. Not to mention Amazon’s poor treatment of warehouse workers, their impact on the environment, and anti-competitive business practices. 

Buy How To Resist Amazon and Why by Danny Caine

Danny Caine is an indie bookstore owner who’s written extensively about the havoc that Amazon wreaks on local economies and small businesses. How To Resist Amazon And Why is a great introductory book into this meaty topic.

Why readers love The StoryGraph

What Goodreads lacks in book tracking customizations, book recommendations, unique reader stats, and more, The StoryGraph more than makes up for. Let’s go through some of the best features:

Book tracking 

The StoryGraph takes book tracking to a whole new level. When you search for a book to add, you can choose from four different statuses: “to read”, “read”, “currently reading,” and “did not finish.” When you toggle that book to “currently reading”, you’ll then also see “paused” and “remove book” as options.

Like Goodreads, you can also add start and end dates, as well as track your reading progress by updating your page numbers. 

You can even start digitizing your personal library by marking a book as owned, or add it to your favorites, which you can then display on your profile’s shelf.

A screenshot of the way a book page looks on The Storygraph. The Odyssey is displayed. Compare The Storygraph vs Goodreads.
This is how a book page looks on the desktop version of The Storygraph. On the right-hand side, you’ll see all of the book tracking options available to you.

✦ Jeimy’s tips

If you’re reading an audiobook or ebook, make sure you add that specific edition to your TBR. The StoryGraph will then track your progress using the correct format—hours and minutes for audiobooks instead of page numbers.

Book reviews

When you mark a book as “read” on The StoryGraph, you’ll be able to write a review for it. You can  even rate your books by .25 star increments. Truthfully, I’ve used .25 and .75 more often than I thought I would.

In addition to having your standard bold, italic, and strikethrough options for text, you can also include a header, quotes, and bulleted/numbered lists. If you’re including more than a summary in your review, make sure to highlight the section and click on the “spoiler” button to warn other readers.

The book review user experience on The Storygraph, showing Still Writing by Dani Shapiro.

Last but not least, don’t forget to include content warnings in your reviews! (We’ll go over this feature in detail in a later section.)

✦ Jeimy’s tips

Take a few extra seconds to tag the mood of each book you’ve read—whether it’s adventurous, emotional, funny, or something else. It helps The StoryGraph recommend better books and makes it easier for other mood readers to find their next great read.

Reading stats 

If you’re active on Bookstagram or BookTok, you may have first heard about The StoryGraph because of their year-end reading wrap-up—and for good reason! 

One of the best features of the platform is the fact that your personal reading stats are available to you at any time, and you can filter them by books you’ve read, your DNF and TBR lists, and books you own. 

A screenshot of The Storygraph's reading stats, saying "40 books, 15,344 pages" read and an average time to finish of 15 days.
Here is a visualization of my personal reading stats page from 2025.

Right at the start, you’ll see the number of books you’ve read, the number of pages, and the average time it takes you to finish a book.

Then you get a bunch of nifty graphs and charts:

  • A mood breakdown of the books you’ve read.
  • A chart showing how many books you’ve read in each pacing category: slow, medium, and fast.
  • A breakdown of the average length of the books you’ve read.
  • A comparison of your fiction versus nonfiction reading.
  • A graph showing how many books you’ve read in each genre.
  • A breakdown of your reading formats, including print, ebook, and audiobook.
  • A ranking of your most-read authors.
  • A breakdown of the languages you’ve read in.
  • A month-by-month chart showing the number of books and pages you’ve read throughout the year.
  • A distribution of your star ratings, showing how often you give each rating.
A reading stat pie chart of 56% nonfiction and 44% fiction.
A breakdown of my fiction vs. nonfiction reads in 2026. Reading more nonfiction is unusual for me, haha.

The sheer amount of data we get access to is pretty incredible! As a trilingual girlie who mostly reads books in English, this actively reminds me to pick up books in Spanish and Portuguese every once in a while. 

✦ Jeimy’s tips

Your reading stats are interactive! Click on any section of your reading charts to see the books that make up that category. It’s a fun way to dive deeper into your reading habits.

Book recommendations 

The StoryGraph generates a few book recommendation lists that are unique to you as a reader. When you first login, you’ll have the chance to add your reading preferences to your profile. 

The Storygraph's search bar and main menu, which drops down to display your profile, notifications, account management, preferences, and sign out pages.
Click on your profile’s icon on the top right-hand corner to see “Preferences” on the menu.

You’ll be asked about your favorite and least favorite genres, characteristics, and moods. Add in five of your favorite books for the algorithm to reference. As of this writing, “content to avoid” and “Disliked topics, themes, and tropes” is currently in Beta.

A screenshot of The Storygraph's reading preferences section.
These are the customized reading preferences I’ve adding to my StoryGraph account to get personalized recommendations.

Where to find book recommendations on The StoryGraph

On both the desktop and mobile apps, you should see a “Recommendations” section right underneath your “To-read pile” on the homepage.

When you click on this, you’ll be led to a page with over five custom recommendation lists based on your stated preferences, recent reads, and your top genres. You’ll even get  “Similar users loved…” and “Out of your comfort zone” lists.

✦ Jeimy’s tips

Looking for something specific? Open Advanced Search to fine-tune your recommendations. You can add up to three books with a similar vibe, filter by reading moods, and use Extra Filters to narrow your results by pace, genre, page count, and more.

A screenshot of The Storygraph's recommendation's search tool.
Once you click on the “Advanced search” button at the top right hand corner of your Recommendations page, you’ll see the options above.

Community features 

The StoryGraph includes a few nifty features for connecting with other readers on the platform. You can add friends or simply follow them, both of which will influence who shows up on your news feed on the Community page.  

There, you can see the books your community has started and finished reading, as well as their book reviews. 

The Storygraph's community age, which displays a newsfeed with your friends/followers' activity.
On the Community page, you can access your newsfeed, buddy reads, readalongs, book clubs, and find recommendations for new users to follow.

✦ Jeimy’s tips

You can edit who can see your reading updates, owned books, and who can send you a friend request in the Preferences section of your app. 

Buddy reads

If you’ve ever wanted a more formal way of tracking your buddy read with a friend, now you have it. 

When you go to a book’s page, you can “Start a buddy read,” which will prompt you to add a description and end date (both are optional), and invite your reading buddies. Make sure that your friends have buddy read invites enabled in their Community Preferences! 

The view for the Buddy Read feature on The Storygraph.
This is my buddy read with one of my best friends from college.

One of the coolest parts of the Buddy Reads feature is that you can leave comments for your reading partner without worrying about spoilers. Your notes stay hidden until they reach the page that corresponds with your comment. 

(And yes, The StoryGraph takes into account different editions and their page numbers when syncing comments across your Buddy Read!) 

Challenges

When you go to the Challenges page, you’ll be able to set personal reading goals and also join challenges from The StoryGraph community.

There are three types of yearly goals you can set for yourself:

  • Reading goal: Add how many books you want to read.
  • Pages goal: Add how many pages you want to read.
  • Hours goal: Add how many hours you want to listen.

When you click on “Add a challenge,” you’ll see an entire directory of challenges, where you can search by category or even add your own.

A screenshot from The Storygraph's challenge directory, with three challenges hosted by The Storygraph displayed at the top of the page.
Choose from one of The StoryGraph’s official challenges, create your own, or join a challenge created by another user.

Other features under the community tab include “Readalongs,” which function as mini book clubs with checkpoints, and an actual “Book Club,” which you can add a logo, description, and code of conduct for. 

Content warnings

The book space is long overdue when it comes to providing content warnings, especially compared to other mediums like tv, film, and even social media platforms. 

The StoryGraph makes it easier to avoid topics you don’t want to read about. First, you can specifically add content you don’t want to read in the Reading Preferences section I mentioned before. This is the best way to make sure that the algorithm removes these books from your recommended lists.

Secondly, when you go to a book’s individual page, you can scroll all the way down to where it says “Content warnings” and click on the “View summary” to expand the list. There, you’ll see mentioned topics split into graphic, moderate, and minor mentions. 

✦ Jeimy’s tips

One small habit can make a big difference: include content warnings when you review a book. You’ll help other readers decide whether a book is the right fit for them.

What Goodreads still does better

Goodreads set the precedent for what book tracking apps look and feel like. Let’s go over a few popular features that still make it a strong choice for some readers.

A screenshot of the way a book page looks on Goodreads. Colored Television is displayed. Compare The Storygraph vs Goodreads.
Take a look at how Goodreads displays their book pages. The number of ratings and reviews are prominently displayed next to the book’s cover.

Existing reader network

As the platform with the largest number of users, Goodreads tends to be one of the easiest online places to find community with other readers. Chances are that your friends in real life are on Goodreads, and if you stumble upon readers on social media, you’ll be able to find their Goodreads account, too. 

Many readers value community-driven suggestions, and Goodreads easily surfaces book recommendations, ratings, and reviews from people that you follow.

Goodreads’ annual reading goals challenge is also incredibly popular, and setting a yearly reading goal—along with being able to see others’—helps keep readers accountable to their reading habits. 

Rich book reviews

The large reader network also powers the rich book review culture that Goodreads is known for. We can look at the benefits from two angles: users who like to read book reviews, and users who like to post book reviews.

For the first camp, Goodreads prominently shows how many users gave the book each star rating. You can also filter book reviews (for example, newest vs. oldest first), by edition, and by language. 

Community reviews on Goodreads for the book Colored Television, showing the breakdown between the percentage and number of users who rated the book 5, 4, 3, 2, and 1 star.
Goodreads displays the amount and percentage of people who rank books 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 stars. This is the data from Colored Television by Danzy Senna.

You can even engage with reviews by liking or commenting on them, which fosters even more discussions about the book.

For the second camp, Goodreads encourages users who like to post book reviews with social recognition and gamification. For example, the platform has a ranking list for most reviewed and best reviewers—which will show up on your profile—and will also surface the most popular reviews beneath each book listing.

Goodreads <> Kindle integration

The Kindle dominates market share when it comes to ereaders. Because Goodreads and Kindle are owned by Amazon, the integration between both is a key reason why many users value their book tracking platform.

When you’re reading on your Kindle, it automatically updates the book to “Currently reading” on your Goodreads account. After you finish reading, your Kindle will prompt you to rate the book, which will show up on your Goodreads ratings. This also means that if you set a yearly reading goal, it’ll update automatically! 

Amazon also makes it easy for you to buy books from them. On Goodreads, you can buy an ebook right from the book’s listing page, which will show up on your Kindle. 

These integrations reduce friction for readers, which can allow them to focus less on tracking their reading and more on actually reading.

StoryGraph vs Goodreads: The biggest difference is the reading experience 

Knowing the kind of reading experience you value will be the most important factor in choosing The StoryGraph vs. Goodreads. 

Do you depend on book reviews to decide what to read next? How niche do you like your book recommendations? Do you value using ethical products and services? Do you enjoy having easy access to other readers’ goals and activities? 

I love using The StoryGraph for the following reasons:

  • Book details are important to me. I don’t just want to save any book to my TBR: I want to find the right edition, language, and mark it as “owned” if I purchased it.
  • The platform feels calmer. It’s not cluttered by ads or the opinions of other readers. I can judge a book by its cover, read the summary, and decide whether I want to read it, all before ever seeing someone’s review. 
  • The reading stats are unparalleled. I frequently dig into my own data to learn about my reading habits and decide on what I want to change. 
  • It’s easy to buddy read: Being able to set up a digital “home” for my buddy reading experience makes it even more special, especially when my friends and I are reading different book editions at different paces.

Can you use The StoryGraph and Goodreads together?

If you’re still deciding between The StoryGraph vs Goodreads, the good news is that you don’t necessarily have to choose. Plenty of readers use both apps, but how well it works depends on what you’re using them for.

If you’re tracking every book on both platforms, you’ll need to update each app whenever you finish a book (or periodically if you don’t mind your stats being a little behind).

That said, I think the better approach is to let each app do what it does best.

For example, you might use The StoryGraph to manage your TBR, track your reading progress, and get personalized recommendations, while using Goodreads to browse reviews and see what your friends are reading.

Or you could keep Goodreads as your primary reading log but use StoryGraph for Buddy Reads, book clubs, and its detailed reading statistics.

If each app offers something you enjoy, there’s no reason you can’t take advantage of the best features of both.

Can I import my book history into StoryGraph?

Yes! If you’ve been using Goodreads for years, you don’t have to start over. 

Here are the steps I took to import my data to The StoryGraph (and it’s a lot less daunting than it sounds!) :

  1. Export your Goodreads library as a CSV file from the Import and Export page under My Books.
  2. Upload that file to StoryGraph’s Goodreads import tool. 
  3. Depending on the size of your library, the import may take a little while to finish—but once it’s done, you’ll have your books, ratings, reviews, shelves, and reading history ready to explore in The StoryGraph.
  4. That’s it!

If you’d like more information about how to import your book history from Goodreads, The StoryGraph has a summary and step-by-step guide.

Is The StoryGraph free?

Yes—and for most readers, the free version is more than enough. (It’s also the version that I use!) It includes personalized recommendations, thoughtful reading stats, reading challenges, buddy reads, book clubs, and all the mood-based tracking that makes The StoryGraph feel so different from Goodreads. 

If you love digging into your reading data, StoryGraph Plus offers even more detailed insights, personalized charts, and early access to new features. It’s $4.99 per month or $49.99 per year, with a 30-day free trial. But unless you know you’ll enjoy analyzing every corner of your reading life, I’d start with the free version to see how it fits.

Which app is right for your reading life?

When it comes to StoryGraph vs Goodreads, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends on what you want your reading life to feel like.

If you’re a mood reader…
The StoryGraph is the clear winner. It recommends books based on your mood, pacing preferences, and the emotions you’re hoping to experience, making it much easier to find a book that feels right for where you are today.

If you love reviewing books…
Goodreads still has a larger community. If you enjoy writing detailed reviews, following friends, and reading thousands of opinions before picking up a book, you’ll probably appreciate its social side.

If you mostly want recommendations…
The StoryGraph offers more thoughtful recommendations that go beyond genre or popularity. Instead of showing you what’s trending, it tries to match you with the kinds of books you genuinely enjoy reading.

If you’re rebuilding your reading habit…
Goodreads makes it easy to get started. Plus, the social aspect of the app might just be the incentive you need to pick up your book. 

If reading has started to feel like a competition…
The StoryGraph is the app I’d choose every time. If you’ve ever felt discouraged by reading challenges, endless five-star hype, or someone else’s book count, The StoryGraph offers a quieter, more intentional alternative.

Ultimately, The StoryGraph vs Goodreads debate can only be settled by choosing what you currently need—even if that means another Goodreads alternative altogether!

I use The StoryGraph almost every day, and it’s become an important part of my reading life. It helps me choose books based on what I’m actually in the mood for, notice patterns in my reading, and allows me to keep track of my TBR and personal library. 

If that sounds like the kind of reading life you’re trying to build, I think you’ll feel at home there, too!

Similar Posts